
On a limited comparison, VIA Rail is my preference: better equipment and people, smaller lounges. What could change my mind is Amtrak's new Airo trains.
Based on a limited comparison, VIA Rail is my preference.
Limited is the operative word. On VIA, we rode the Québec City–Toronto corridor in business class. On Amtrak, we rode the Southwest Chief, the Cardinal, the Lake Shore Limited, and the Maple Leaf. The fairest match-up is the Maple Leaf against VIA's corridor trains: both are daytime runs of a few hours. That leg feeds my preference.

Where VIA wins
The equipment. The trainset from Québec City to Montréal was impressive. Screens showed our location and time updates from GPS, like on a subway car. The accessible restroom had a large curved door that wraps around. And there were more outlets at the seats than even I needed, and I'm a media-device hound.

The Maple Leaf's Amfleet coach was the other end of it. To be fair, it was coach, so my expectations were lower. But the car was worn out, didn't appear as well maintained, and seemed to reflect a lack of pride.
The people. Service across the whole VIA experience was top-notch. The staff were friendly and helpful at every step.
Where Amtrak holds its own
The lounge. VIA's business lounges in Québec City and Montréal were small and cramped, and they filled before all the business class passengers arrived. The service inside was as good as everywhere else on VIA. There just wasn't room.
Chicago's Metropolitan Lounge is larger and has a few more food and beverage options. The lounge staff are pushy, though, partly because they're lining up passengers to board two, three, or four trains at a time.

The lower-level seats on a Superliner. We ended up in coach on the Southwest Chief unexpectedly, and the lower-level seats are my preference. The section is small, the restrooms are close by, and on rough track the rocking is much less. Upstairs, every restroom trip means the tiny staircase. Downstairs, I can skip the stairs entirely, or take them once for the snack car.
What could change my mind
Amtrak just debuted its newest trains, the Airo, on the Cascades between Vancouver, B.C., Seattle, Portland, and Eugene. They're built on the same Siemens platform as VIA's corridor trains, so the Cascades is the fair test of whether Amtrak's new equipment closes the gap. I haven't ridden it yet.
I also haven't taken VIA across the country. Either one could move me. For now, it's VIA.
You might also like
Before and After the TripFall Color by Train Depends on Which Way You're Riding
On a fall color trip by train, direction matters as much as the date. What our rail-and-cruise anniversary trip showed me about which way to ride.
Choosing the TripOne Name, Four Itineraries: Reading an NCL Panama Canal Sailing
How Norwegian Cruise Line’s four Panama Canal itineraries differ: direction, length, port calls and price, and which one fits your trip.
Choosing the TripThe Winter Canal: NCL's Other Repositioning Cycle
Norwegian Star crosses the Panama Canal from Miami to San Diego in December 2026, runs the Mexican Riviera for ten weeks, and sails back through the canal in February. How the winter repositioning cycle works.